CovOps
 Location : Ether-Sphere
Job/hobbies : Irrationality Exterminator
Humor : Über Serious
 |  Subject: Canada: 19 died after being Tasered  Wed Mar 26, 2008 11:24 pm | |
| RCMP boss orders second look at Taser forms after critics slam secrecy
A joint Canadian Press-CBC investigation has found that the RCMP is stripping key information from public reports on Taser incidents as use of the controversial stun gun skyrockets across the country.
OTTAWA - The RCMP, stung by criticism over secrecy, is rethinking its decision to strip Taser reports of crucial information after the public safety minister demanded a second look.
In a statement late Wednesday, Commissioner William Elliott said he had ordered "a further review" of recently released copies of forms detailing use of the electronic weapons "to determine if additional information" should be released.
"It is anticipated that this review can be completed within two weeks."
A spokesman for Public Safety Minister Stockwell Day said the minister "has asked for and received assurances from the commissioner that the RCMP will further review the matter."
The RCMP announcement came just hours after the police force said it stood by a decision to withhold details of Taser firings, including whether the suspect was armed and any injuries caused by the stun gun.
Sgt. Sylvie Tremblay said the Mounties had released "all the information that could be provided" under the Access to Information Act when it disclosed newly reclassified and heavily censored records last week.
"The RCMP is committed to respecting the public's right to know while upholding the law and protecting the privacy rights of individuals," Tremblay said in an interview.
"Requesters may challenge the RCMP's application of various exemptions . . . should they be dissatisfied with the processing of their request."
Critics said that's a lame excuse for shielding details that were once routinely disclosed.
A joint investigation by The Canadian Press and CBC found the Mounties are now censoring key elements that must be recorded each time officers draw their electronic weapons.
The force no longer reveals whether Tasered people were armed or not, the precise dates of firings, and whether the device caused any burns, cuts or bruises.
As a result, Canadians know much less about who is being hit with the contentious 50,000-volt guns and under what circumstances.
Advocates of more openness point out the names and addresses of Tasered people are already struck from the forms, making further deletions unnecessary.
"The leadership of the RCMP appears to have a tin ear for what the public wants in relation to Taser use," says Frank Addario, president of the Criminal Lawyers' Association.
"It seems obvious that the public wants transparency in relation to the training and circumstances in which this . . . device is used, limitations on its use after any apparent threat to public or officer safety is managed and, above all, thorough training of police officers in advance of using these devices."
Another RCMP spokesman, Troy Lightfoot, has said internal analysis of Taser reports concluded the painful weapons were being used correctly.
Newspaper editorials and opposition critics and newspaper editorials say that amounts to a "just-trust-us" approach.
Opposition MPs on an all-party Commons committee studying Tasers say the force must be held to account.
"I think the RCMP, by doing this, is losing a lot of credibility on the way they handle the Taser," says Bloc Quebecois MP Serge Menard. "It makes us more suspicious.
"One thing is for sure, we're going to examine the documents that you've got, and we'll see if we can get some more ourselves."
The Mounties said they correctly withheld information on the forms under provisions of the information law related to personal privacy and police investigations.
Tremblay had no comment when asked if the RCMP broke the law by previously releasing details that it now insists must be protected.
A Canadian Press analysis last November of 563 cases between 2002 and 2005 found three in four suspects Tasered by the RCMP were unarmed.
Several of those reports suggested a pattern of stun-gun use as a convenient means of keeping drunk or rowdy people in line, rather than to defuse major clashes.
Nineteen people in Canada have died soon after being Tasered.
Manufacturer Taser International stresses that its device has never been directly blamed for a death, although it has been cited as a contributing factor in several cases.
Amnesty International is among observers who've called for a suspension of Taser use pending an independent, comprehensive study of risks and benefits. The weapon is hugely popular with police who say it's a much safer and efficient alternative to the baton, pepper spray and gun.
http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/Canada/2008/03/24/5090246-cp.html |
|
